So Matt’s diatribe last week about pseudo-emo and the certain death knell (at least in terms of reputation) the tag sounds for any band got me thinking about Nada Surf and their 1996 hit, “Popular.” Though really more Weezer impersonators than anything else, NS are, for better or worse, often lumped together with a slew of other borderline emo acts (Jimmy Eat World, The Get Up Kids, SDRE, etc.) that have markedly little in common with the current Dashboard Boy at the Disco contingency. What I find most incredible is that this lack of differentiation has stood up to music listeners’ obsession with subdivision. I mean, I can seriously name three different “kinds” of ambient electronic, and yet the expansive and much-loathed category that is emo features no partitions, leaving bands like Cap’n Jazz automatically (and unfairly—there, said it) on the defensive. Maybe it’s just that nobody’s yet found a cool enough name for the sub-styles—“emo” is a pretty hard word to work with. Anywayz, here’s “Popular,” this emo track about that cruelest of combinations—girls and high school.
One thought on “Thursday Throwback: Popular”
Comments are closed.

Ha, wow I’ve never actually heard anything by NS before Let Go (great album). Drastically different. I agree, it’s pretty strange how all of emo has been lumped together in one giant waste bin of negative connotations. SDRE and Cap’n Jazz are definitely legit bands that just can’t seem to shake that unfortunate title.
Anyway, I just finished up finals today so posts are a-comin’. I have an idea for a series called “Songs That Aren’t Dance Songs But Should Be Danced To”. It’ll be epic.